The Best Burgers in New York City to Try in 2025
New York City is a paradise for food enthusiasts, and burgers are no exception. With countless options ranging from classic American-style burgers to innovative vegan creations, it’s a city where you can truly explore the boundaries of what a burger can be. Whether you're a local or a visitor, navigating the plethora of burger joints can be daunting. This guide to the best burgers in New York City will introduce you to must-visit spots, highlight trends, and showcase why The Grey Dog stands out as the ultimate destination for the best burgers in New York.
What Defines “The Best Burgers”?
The perfect burger isn’t just about the patty—it’s the harmony of fresh ingredients, flavorful sauces, and expertly crafted buns that make the difference. New York’s burger scene in 2025 is vibrant, with restaurants taking bold steps to elevate this classic dish. Grass-fed beef, vegan patties, creative toppings, and sustainable sourcing are defining trends. Amid this innovation, The Grey Dog exemplifies a balance of tradition and creativity, offering burgers that satisfy both classic and modern palates.
A Burger Lover’s Paradise: Why NYC Stands Out
New York City’s burger culture is as diverse as its population. From classic smashburgers to vegan masterpieces, the city’s restaurants take this comfort food staple to gourmet heights. Whether you prefer your burgers dripping with cheese or topped with inventive, seasonal ingredients, NYC’s burger scene has something for everyone.
Among these local gems, The Grey Dog stands out as a haven for burger aficionados. With five convenient locations—Chelsea, Flatiron, Nolita, Union Square, and West Village—The Grey Dog serves up some of the best burgers in New York City, paired with a warm and inviting atmosphere that feels like home.
Must-Try Burgers in NYC for 2025
Here are the top burger picks for the year, spotlighting The Grey Dog and other standout spots in New York.
1. The Grey Dog’s Big House Burger
If you’re looking for a quintessential New York burger, the Big House Burger at The Grey Dog is a must-try. This 8 oz grass-fed beef patty is cooked to perfection and topped with sautéed onions, horseradish sauce, and pickles. You can customize it further with cheddar, Swiss, feta, or American cheese for just $1, or take it to the next level with bacon or avocado for $3 each. Served with your choice of fries or greens (or sweet potato fries for $1 more), this burger is a hearty and wholesome meal that embodies the homestyle goodness The Grey Dog is known for.
2. The Grey Dog’s Vegan Burger
Vegans and vegetarians, rejoice! The Grey Dog offers one of the best vegan burgers in New York. This double-patty Impossible Burger is layered with vegan mozzarella, roasted peppers, fried onions, mushrooms, and vegan chipotle mayo, all on a vegan bun. Whether you’re plant-based or just looking to switch things up, this burger delivers big on flavor without compromising your dietary preferences.
3. Minetta Tavern’s Black Label Burger
Minetta Tavern in Greenwich Village remains a classic spot for burger lovers. The Black Label Burger, made with a proprietary blend of dry-aged beef, is as luxurious as it gets. Served simply with caramelized onions and a buttery bun, it lets the quality of the meat shine through. While it’s on the pricier side, it’s worth every penny.
4. Emily’s Emmy Burger
Emily, a cozy eatery in Brooklyn, serves up the Emmy Burger, a dry-aged beef patty topped with cheddar, caramelized onions, and a tangy special sauce on a pretzel bun. Paired with their signature curly fries, this burger is a local favorite that keeps diners coming back.
Why The Grey Dog is the Home of the Best Burgers in New York
While New York is home to an array of incredible burger joints, The Grey Dog sets itself apart with a focus on quality, variety, and a welcoming atmosphere.
Quality Ingredients
At The Grey Dog, the ingredients are the star. The beef is grass-fed, ensuring a rich, natural flavor, while the vegan burgers showcase innovative, plant-based ingredients that satisfy without compromise. Seasonal and locally sourced elements further enhance each burger.
Customization
Few places offer the level of customization available at The Grey Dog. From cheese and avocado to bacon, you can tailor your burger to perfection. Add a side of sweet potato fries or upgrade to a soup to make it a complete meal.
Versatility and Inclusivity
The Grey Dog doesn’t just serve great food—it serves everyone. Their burgers cater to diverse diets and preferences, offering everything from hearty beef options to fully vegan creations.
A Focus on Community
The Grey Dog isn’t just a burger spot—it’s a destination for any time of day. Whether it’s brunch, dinner, or happy hour, the menu offers something for everyone, ensuring that all guests leave satisfied.
Your Next Stop for the Best Burgers in New York City
The search for the best burgers in New York City ends at The Grey Dog. Whether you’re savoring the classic Big House Burger or delighting in the plant-based Vegan Burger, every bite is a testament to quality and flavor. With locations in Chelsea, Flatiron, Nolita, Union Square, and West Village, there’s always a Grey Dog nearby to satisfy your cravings.
If you’re looking for a spot to enjoy a casual meal, host a private event, or simply indulge in one of the best burgers in New York, make The Grey Dog your next stop. Visit us today or contact us to book a reservation, learn about our menu, or plan your next gathering. We can’t wait to serve you!